Sangiacomo, Andrea ; Navhtomy, Oscar:
Spinoza's Rethinking of Activity : From the 'Short Treatise' to the 'Ethics'

In: The Southern Jorunal of Philosophy 56, 1 (2018), 101-126

Literature type: Articles
Language: English
Thematic areas: Anthropology / psychology / doctrine of affections / body and mind
Subject: E, KV

English commentary: This paper argues that God's immanent causation and Spinoza's account of activity as adequate causation (of finite modes) do not always go together in Spinoza's thought. We show that there is good reason to doubt that this is the case in Spinoza's early Short Treatise on God, Man and His Well‐being. In the Short Treatise, Spinoza defends an account of God's immanent causation without fully endorsing the account of activity as adequate causation that he will later introduce in the Ethics (E3def2). We turn to an examination of how God's immanent causation relates to the activity of finite things in the Ethics. We consider two ways to think about the link between God, seen as immanent cause, and the activity of finite things: namely, in terms of entailment and in terms of production. We argue that the productive model is most promising for understanding the way in which the activity of finite things and God's immanent causality are connected in Spinoza's (mature) philosophy. (abstract)URL: http://https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/sjp.12266

Link to this page: http://spinoza.hab.de/detail.php?id=19993&LANG=EN